Monday, April 21, 2008

Men in uniform

For everyone who has often seen Barkha Dutt of NDTV conduct shows on the channel, she must come across as dictatorial. The fact is she is. I have been on We, The People, a show on NDTV several times and each time I have found that she indulges the celebrity invitees to the show and ignores the participating audience to a large extent.

And yet, I am willing to put aside her misgivings as an anchor as there is something I admire about her. Her passion for the men in uniform. A passion I share with her.

Flying back from Delhi last weekend, I read this article in the Hindustan Times. Read it HERE.

When I read it, tears formed in my eyes. For once, I wish I had written that story.

I’ve been the wife of a defence officer. (We are out of the uniform, but in many ways, the uniform still stays with us). And I have lived the life she has described.

Outside the Defence, all the tax payers of the country, look upon the Services perhaps as a glamorous career option..that wasn’t meant for them.

I have heard people complaining about the corruption in the Armed Forces, the “free ration” we get (Mind you, NOTHING is free….the money for it being compensated somewhere in our dismal salary packages), the so-called perks (Canteen and Medical services…) and some times absurdities like “you get what we pay out of our tax money” (Excuse me, but we pay our taxes honestly too.)

I agree. Corruption is taking root, one step at a time in the Armed Forces. Which public service will not have a few rotten tomatoes? But does that mean the entire vegetable basket is to be condemned?

When we raise a finger at a Brigadier stooping to issue undue favours in return for a mere gold chain (as was exposed in the Tehekla expose) do we stop to think that after 25+ years of service why he would risk condemnation?

The abysmal pay packets have a story of their own to tell. Until the recommendations of the Sixth Pay Commission are enforced, the average carry-home package of an Officer with SEVENTEEN years of Service is about Rs30,000. Enough to pay a Home Instalment, a car loan etc?

That’s how much a friend with two years of work experience in the call center industry was earning. As a bachelor, it was more than he could ask for.

But imagine a family sustaining themselves through outings, vacations, extra stuff for schools, uniforms, groceries, other essentials, fuel, compulsory savings etc on that meagre income. A family of four mind you!

Lets not discount the other contingencies such as an ailing parent who cannot be treated at the Military Hospital, or an out of turn transfer which will land you in a city where Defence accommodation is unavailable (You might be put on a roster), so you end up taking a home on rent, paying market price for it. Or consider that after staying in this rented accommodation, you have to move to a Defence dwelling, and you shell out the money for the local transfer yourself.

And here I speak of Officers. One cannot fathom the plight of jawans, sailors and airmen who are even forced to share family accomodation (one flat amongst two families) due to shortage of official accomodation, or those who die fighting terrorists in "peace time" receiving no extra compensation...and a two line mention in the left hand bottom corner of a newspaper that could be used to line a garbage bin.

Glamorous. Yes. Lots of parties and a life of dancing and merry making….

But that is one side of the coin. All the partying and merry making can get tedious when you have to pay for each of them and attending them is “compulsory”.

I agree that the Defence is a non-profit making sector, so all the expenses that go towards disbursement of salaries, upkeep of establishments, procurement of equipment etc are just EXPENSES. But can we do without it? Can we do without the two lakh personnel posted in J&K fighting terrorism? Or guarding our shores and skies?

The morale of the man in uniform is at an all time low. Read stories in newspapers about the brewing dissent... jawans shooting at their superiors etc, and you’ll know that the situation is grim.

The sense of pride a uniform evokes is, in this materialistic world, temporary and transitory. Weighed on the yardsticks of success and happiness, it falls way below the mark.

Patriotism is not enough reason to join the Armed Forces. They need more. Give them more. Or they will, like my husband did, flock out, one by one, for several reasons, seeking happiness, contentment, success and money, elsewhere.

8 comments:

The Seeker said...

Hullo. Its quite true, what u said, people have these assumptions, Life is easy for defence people, for that matter, it never was, for anyone. Some of my friends father were in army. it is not easy for those kids to keep changing schoos, for the families to keep shifting homes. good post. Its good that u wrote about it, for only people who have been thru it can know what it is. And as u said, its not just patriotism, its more to it.

Unknown said...

Hi Barath, thanks......

AmitL said...

I totally agree-a Defence person's life is never easy-constant transfers,low salaries,risk to life...I'm sure,if they want,the govt can do a lot to raise their standard of living(Insteading of giving themselves fat salary raises each year).But,do they want to??
And,if they don't want to,they have to accept corruption...anything goes,when it comes to a case of having to make two ends meet.

Romila said...

I've often thought aloud on the logical reason behind giving such dismal salary to defence personnel. When what they face is far beyond what a normal family faces, what with surrendering their lives for the safeguard of the country, uprootment every few years, sometimes to places where a family with kids needs a lot of adjustment.

Recently when the govt. announced a good increment for central services, I am glad that the govt. has done smthing that shd be done much earlier.

Vineet Rajan said...

i really liked how u presented the case here. men in uniform have been subject to a lot and we are this close to the breaking point. inflection point? yeah. why should one join the army when so much stress is laid on making more money and living a more comfortable life. and those who do, have to face this. just not done.

Unknown said...

***Hi Amit... I agree with ur view point. hence the post.

***Hey Romila, the increment only sounds good :-( It is actually going to raise salry levels by about 5-7000 only...which will be stuck again till the next Pay Commission is formulated some 5 years later...

***Hi Vinni, you are absolutely right...

Arunima said...

One of my Uncle and my cousin are in the army and now, my brother-in-law is passing out of the National Defence Academy, this month end. I'll be there for the ceremony. he is one of the best cadet in the academy and is already a leader.

I am one of those people who take pride in saying that I have someone in the defence.

I can only hope that the pay commissions revise and revise their compensations well for what they stand for.

Read your previous post on this and read Barkha's article too. ass licking does happen even in the corporate world, but as you said, you cannot waste the basket just because of some rotten tomatoes, you don't always get your promotion because you have licked asses.

My uncle is a Brigadier now. He has received galantry awards for fighting in Kargil and I think he deserved it. Some people are unlucky that they have had to work under bosses who prefer ass licking than performance.

Unknown said...

Hi Arunima, totally totally agree with u. If you're gonna come to Pune give me a buzz. Maybe we can grab a cup of coffee! Will leave this message on ur blog as well!!!